Some dishes just disappear from the dinner table without warning—and we’re still thinking about them. These 23 forgotten recipes aren’t trendy, but they’re the kind people secretly hope will show up again. They’re rich with history, packed with memory, and too good to stay lost. If you’ve been craving a reminder of what real comfort looks like, you’re in the right place.
Pasulj Serbian White Bean Soup
Pasulj is a hearty Serbian white bean soup that once graced many family tables. Its simple ingredients and comforting flavors make it a classic example of forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made. This dish is both filling and light, perfect for chilly evenings. Bringing it back could warm more than just the stomach.
Get the Recipe: Pasulj Serbian White Bean Soup
Chicken Marbella
A standout from the 1980s, Chicken Marbella combines sweet prunes and briny olives for a flavor that's hard to forget. It's one of those forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, especially for special occasions. The dish's unique taste profile sets it apart from modern meals. Reviving it might just bring back the charm of retro dinner parties.
Get the Recipe: Chicken Marbella
Stuffed Potato Patties With A Mushroom Filling
These stuffed potato patties, filled with savory mushrooms, are reminiscent of meals made from pantry staples. As one of the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, they showcase resourcefulness and flavor. Easy to prepare and satisfying, they fit well into today's cooking routines. Their return could add variety to everyday meals.
Get the Recipe: Stuffed Potato Patties With A Mushroom Filling
Vegetarian Ukrainian Borscht
Ukrainian borscht, with its vibrant beet base, is a soup that tells a story of tradition and resilience. It's among the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, offering both nutrition and nostalgia. The vegetarian version keeps it accessible for modern diets. Serving it could reconnect us with cultural roots.
Get the Recipe: Vegetarian Ukrainian Borscht
Pouding Chomeur With Homemade Date Syrup
Originating during the Great Depression, Pouding Chomeur is a dessert born out of necessity. It's one of those forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, reminding us of simpler times. The homemade date syrup adds a rich sweetness that complements the cake's texture. Reintroducing it could offer a sweet lesson in history.
Get the Recipe: Pouding Chomeur With Homemade Date Syrup
Homemade Gefilte Fish Recipe With Beet Chrein
Gefilte fish, often served during Jewish holidays, is a dish steeped in tradition. As one of the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, it represents a connection to cultural heritage. The accompanying beet chrein adds a spicy kick that balances the fish's mild flavor. Bringing it back could honor ancestral culinary practices.
Get the Recipe: Homemade Gefilte Fish Recipe With Beet Chrein
Argentinian Flan (Bread Pudding) With Caramel Sauce
This Argentinian flan transforms leftover bread into a creamy dessert topped with caramel sauce. It's among the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, showcasing ingenuity in the kitchen. The dessert's rich texture and sweet finish make it a crowd-pleaser. Reviving it could reduce waste and delight palates.
Get the Recipe: Argentinian Flan (Bread Pudding) With Caramel Sauce
Classic Matzo Brei Recipe (Eggy Fried Matzah)
Matzo brei is a simple yet satisfying dish combining matzah and eggs, often enjoyed during Passover. It's one of those forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, offering comfort with minimal ingredients. Quick to prepare, it suits both breakfast and dinner. Its comeback could simplify meal planning.
Get the Recipe: Classic Matzo Brei Recipe (Eggy Fried Matzah)
Russian Potato Salad (Olivier Salad)
Olivier Salad, a Russian staple, mixes diced vegetables with a creamy dressing for a hearty side dish. As one of the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, it brings a festive touch to any table. Its versatility allows for various ingredient additions. Reintroducing it could add color to gatherings.
Get the Recipe: Russian Potato Salad (Olivier Salad)
Apple-Granola Baked Bimuelos (Hanukkah Honey Puffs)
These baked bimuelos offer a healthier take on traditional Hanukkah treats, combining apples and granola. They're among the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, blending tradition with modern tastes. The honey syrup glaze adds a touch of sweetness without overwhelming. Their return could bridge generations during holiday celebrations.
Get the Recipe: Apple-Granola Baked Bimuelos (Hanukkah Honey Puffs)
Cold Haddock In Carrot Lemon Sauce
Cold haddock topped with a carrot lemon sauce offers a refreshing seafood option that's light yet flavorful. It's one of those forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, especially during warmer months. The dish's simplicity highlights the fish's natural taste. Bringing it back could diversify summer menus.
Get the Recipe: Cold Haddock In Carrot Lemon Sauce
Bosnian Pita Pie
Bosnian pita pie, with its flaky layers and savory fillings, is a dish that showcases Balkan culinary traditions. As one of the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, it represents the art of homemade pastries. The pie's versatility allows for various fillings to suit different tastes. Reviving it could inspire more home baking adventures.
Get the Recipe: Bosnian Pita Pie
Traditional Russian Blintzes
Russian blintzes are thin pancakes filled with sweet or savory mixtures, often enjoyed during special occasions. They're among the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, offering a canvas for culinary creativity. The process of making them can be a communal activity. Their resurgence could foster togetherness in the kitchen.
Get the Recipe: Traditional Russian Blintzes
Russian Piroshki
Piroshki are Russian hand pies filled with meats, vegetables, or cheeses, perfect for on-the-go meals. As one of the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, they combine convenience with comfort. The dough's softness encases flavorful fillings that satisfy hunger quickly. Bringing them back could offer a homemade alternative to fast food.
Get the Recipe: Russian Piroshki
Beatrice's Icelandic Pickled Beets
Pickled beets, a staple in Icelandic cuisine, provide a tangy accompaniment to various dishes. They're among the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, adding color and flavor to meals. The pickling process preserves the beets' nutrients while enhancing taste. Reintroducing them could brighten up modern plates.
Get the Recipe: Beatrice's Icelandic Pickled Beets
Mujadara
Mujadara combines lentils and rice topped with caramelized onions, offering a protein-rich vegetarian meal. It's one of those forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, emphasizing simplicity and nutrition. The dish's ingredients are pantry staples, making it accessible. Its return could support meatless meal planning.
Get the Recipe: Mujadara
Russian Vinaigrette Salad (Root Vegetable Salad)
This salad mixes root vegetables with a light dressing, creating a colorful and nutritious side dish. As one of the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, it brings variety to vegetable preparations. The combination of textures and flavors keeps it interesting. Reviving it could encourage more vegetable consumption.
Get the Recipe: Russian Vinaigrette Salad (Root Vegetable Salad)
Sweet Matzo Brei Recipe
A sweet variation of matzo brei adds sugar and cinnamon for a dessert-like twist on the traditional dish. It's among the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, offering a quick treat with familiar ingredients. The dish's adaptability allows for various toppings. Bringing it back could satisfy sweet cravings without much effort.
Get the Recipe: Sweet Matzo Brei Recipe
Israeli Rugelach
Rugelach, with its flaky pastry and sweet fillings, is a beloved treat in Israeli and Jewish communities. As one of the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, it represents the joy of homemade baked goods. The pastries can be customized with different jams or nuts. Their resurgence could sweeten snack times.
Get the Recipe: Israeli Rugelach
Grandma's Molasses Cookies
Molasses cookies, with their rich flavor and chewy texture, are reminiscent of grandma's kitchen. They're among the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, evoking memories of childhood. The spices used add depth to the cookie's taste. Baking them again could bring comfort during cold seasons.
Get the Recipe: Grandma's Molasses Cookies
Hearty Penna Dutch Potato Salad
This Pennsylvania Dutch potato salad features a tangy dressing and hearty ingredients, making it a robust side dish. It's one of those forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, especially for picnics and gatherings. The salad's balance of flavors complements various mains. Reintroducing it could enhance outdoor meals.
Get the Recipe: Hearty Penna Dutch Potato Salad
Old Fashioned Hummingbird Cake
Hummingbird cake combines bananas, pineapple, and pecans for a moist and flavorful dessert. As one of the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, it brings Southern charm to the table. The cream cheese frosting adds a creamy finish that pairs well with the cake's sweetness. Baking it again could impress at potlucks.
Get the Recipe: Old Fashioned Hummingbird Cake
Banana Pudding Cookies
These cookies capture the essence of banana pudding in a portable form, combining nostalgia with convenience. They're among the forgotten recipes everyone secretly wishes they still made, perfect for picnics and lunchboxes. The cookies' soft texture and banana flavor appeal to many. Their comeback could add variety to dessert options.
Get the Recipe: Banana Pudding Cookies
Tell Me What You Think!